Emotional Damages Permitted for Violations of the Federal Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act
03-10-10
By:Nicole Dunn, MPLP Law Clerk
In Wienart v GMAC Mortgage Corp, No. 08-CV-14482 (ED
Mich, Sept 29, 2009) the Eastern District of Michigan held that emotional
distress damages are permitted under the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act
(RESPA).In Wienart, the mortgagor
sued her mortgagee for violating RESPA by, among other things, taking unearned
fees and reporting overdue payments to a credit agency after plaintiff had sent
a written request for information on the status of her mortgage.In addition to her actual damages, mortgagor
sought emotional damages under RESPA, 12 USC 2605(f)(1)(A) (“Whoever fails to
comply with any provision of this
section shall be liable . . . .”)Mortgagee argued that emotional damages are only permitted for
violations of section 26059(e)(3) (reporting negative payment information
during the 60-day period after receiving qualified written request).However, the court found that emotional
damages are part of the “actual damages” portion of 12 USC 2605(f).Therefore, recovery for emotional distress
damages is available under section 2605(f) of RESPA.